I really tried to finish this. I really did. But in all honesty, I couldn't bear it any longer. I came into this novel having seen the absolutely amazing fanart out there and everyone praising how great these characters are. And to be honest, I didn't mind it at first.
In the beginning, the comedy was funny and the main character was interesting and likable. I can't say the same for the side characters though because other than Nan Feng and Fu Yao you don't get much.
And there's where the problems start. The more you learn about the Xie Lian and, later, Hua Cheng, the more unlikable those two start to become. Their romance is awkward and it never fits in the scenes that they are in. Together they are just too OP over all the other characters to the point where it becomes condescending and annoying. And it really doesn't make sense how HC who is the Ghost King and natural enemy of the gods could walk around and hang out with XL without any problems from the other gods. Don't they think that it's strange that XL and HC are so cozy? Wouldn't they be suspicious of both of them? Why isn't there a rule about gods being friends with ghosts if their jobs are to eliminate dangerous ghosts???
Spoiler
Hell at one point XL is walking around the Ghost City and sees a butcher chopping up humans bodies... but he is just grossed out by the sight of it. Shouldn't he be against something like this? Shouldn't after he comes back to the ghost city he should kill the butcher who is killing humans? Isn't protecting humans his job? Why is he okay with all of the ghost in the ghost city as a heavenly official???
SPOILERS FROM HERE ON OUT:
I'll start with the things that I liked.
The side characters:
After the story gets moving (which takes forever well into the 3rd book) the side characters get more fleshed out. Especially the Wind and Water brothers. Their stories in what the Water brother did for his younger brother to protect him from having a horrible fate and the way that he died doing pretty much what the Xie Lain was trying to do but succeeded in where XL failed, was honestly the most badass thing. I was really sad that he had to die but I was cheering him on the whole way.
And even though I thought the Wind Master was annoying at first, he eventually grew on me and every time he showed up I was honestly wishing this story was about him and his brother instead.
Qi Rong was also a really fun character. Even though he is shown to be really horrible and detestable, he is really funny and after a while, I was starting to agree with some of the stuff he was saying about XL. He was definitely more interesting than XL and I'm sad that he didn't have much screen time.
.... And that's it. That's all I liked.
The things that I disliked was pretty much everything else.
The MC was OP as hell and came off as condescending and selfish throughout the entire story. Like this is his story, but he doesn't even have any motivations or a goal or anything! Like he says he wants to help the common people, but he hasn't done that at all! The only time he has helped anyone is because either someone told him to (a mission), he was curious (the whole desert adventure), or he needed something like food or supplies from the villagers, so he helps them out in exchange for praying at his temple or giving him food.
Not once did he go out of his way to help anyone out of selflessness. But somehow I'm supposed to believe that he is the kindest purest person? Even when he promised to take care of Yang Ling, he never paid one ounce of attention to the kid until HC disguised himself as him.
Which is another thing. Whenever XL and HC are together they completely ruin whatever scene they are in with their out of place romance. Numerous times they are put in dangerous situations and the tension is supposed to be high. But every time, without fail, the two of them go off to the side to flirt for no reason. And it's always inappropriate.
Like every time HC comes around XL completely loses interest in his friends and the people he is supposed to be protecting to fawn all over HC. Like when his cousin QR possessed a little boy's father, during the time when the ghosts go into heat, he threatens to eat the boy as he is running away. Instead of going after QR and saving the defenseless child, XL turns around and tries to help HC who is a grown-ass man and the Ghost King on top of that! And the kid is literally forgotten about and in the hands of a psychotic human eating ghost. XL really has no priorities to anyone but himself and HC.
And this sort of thing happens all the time. XL gets into a new adventure that has nothing to do with him, HC shows up to cause some awkward flirting, XL and HC solves the mystery in seconds while dismissing everyone else and pretty much calling them idiots, some action happens, some more mystery happens but nothing is solved this time because XL becomes bored and goes home.
It's like when the Wind Master was kidnapped by He Xuan after his brother was killed. XL could've looked for him or show some sort of worry for him, but he went home to find HC and romanced more and forgot all about his friend who is probably in danger.
The story is really flawed too. The entirety of Book 2 was a flashback of XL's life from before he ascended to just before he was banished, and it is entirely pointless. Aside from telling us how HC and XL met, the flashback didn't tell us anything we weren't told already. If anything I think the story should have started out with the flashback and worked with improving XL's character and making him learn from his mistakes. All it did, though, was make me think that XL is a stubborn idiot who could have avoided major disasters if he just listened to people. And the worst thing about it was that HC pretty much validated his flawed thinking by saying that XL should continue to do whatever he wanted because he was right. (Except he wasn't and things blew up in his face because he was wrong about everything.)
I really wanted to like this story and I started out enjoying it, but it was a real struggle after a while because XL and HC were just the worst people in the story. But hey if you like nonsensical and inappropriate romance with OP main characters who have little regard for everyone around them, then be my guest. But I'm tapping out here.